Dr. Al Danenberg ● Nutritional Periodontist
January 6, 2020
I am making a major change in my diet. As with my entire unconventional cancer journey, I continue to experiment and think “outside of the box”. My current research is suggesting that there are potential benefits to replacing my Paleo-type diet with the Carnivore Diet in my Daily Cancer Protocols. While there is no peer-reviewed published trials which I could find where the Carnivore Diet has been designed to treat cancer patients, there are anecdotal reports and case studies that are impressive. The Carnivore Diet is similar to a ketogenic diet but with all fruits, vegetables, nuts and seeds removed.
A ketogenic diet reduces carbohydrates and increases healthy fats to a level where the body’s metabolism shifts away from burning carbs to burning fat and ketones for energy. The Carnivore Diet requires eating only wild-caught and pastured animals from nose-to-tail. Since the Carnivore Diet completely eliminates all plants, it importantly avoids the abundance of antinutrients (i.e. lectins and oxalates) found in plants.
Lectins
Lectins are proteins, which plants produce to defend themselves against animals trying to eat them. Lectins will cause digestive upset, particularly when eaten raw. These proteins are found in roots, stems, leaves, and especially in the seeds of many plants.
After we eat lectins, they bind to the sugar portions of our intestinal wall where they interfere with digestion and nutrient uptake. However, after edible seeds are cooked using moist heat, some of the damaging effects of many lectins may be reduced. Yet, the danger of lectins is real.[1]
Oxalates
Oxalates, which are tiny molecules found in a variety of seeds, nuts and many vegetables, will bind minerals like calcium and form crystals. Oxalates also can cause kidney stones and are responsible for a wide variety of other health problems related to inflammation, autoimmunity, mitochondrial dysfunction, mineral balance, connective tissue integrity, urinary tract issues and poor gut function.
Sally K. Norton wrote an excellent article about the health hazards of oxalates.[2] Medical research also has shown that oxalates promote the transformation of normal breast cells into highly malignant and undifferentiated tumors.[3] Specifically, oxalates have been shown to damage mitochondria.[4] And mitochondrial dysfunction is a primary component in the development of cancer.[5]
My Research
In 2016, a case study was published of a 60-year old patient who had a malignant myoepithelial tumor of the soft palate. The patient refused conventional chemotherapy and radiation treatment. Instead, the patient started a paleolithic-ketogenic (paleo/keto) diet in December 2014. For the first six months, the patient followed a strict meat and fat only diet (Carnivore Diet). From July 2015 on, she was allowed to eat small amounts of vegetables less than two times a week. Surprisingly, the cancer progression was halted as evidenced by imaging follow-up. After 20 months and the conclusion of the case report, the patient had no symptoms or side effects from the originally diagnosed cancer.[6]
During my research, I also came upon another cancer patient. Andrew Scarborough was diagnosed with an aggressive and incurable brain tumor (Grade 3 Anaplastic Astrocytoma) at the age of 27. He elected to treat his cancer with a strict paleo/keto diet, which he modified into a strict Carnivore Diet. Two years after his diagnosis, his cancer was in remission. And his protocol and results are being studied by Hammersford Hospital in Australia.[7]
In a 2018 review of medical papers, the authors found a ketogenic diet reduced the production and growth of most cancer tumors. However, in some isolated types of cancer, a ketogenic diet apparently supported the growth of tumor cells.[8]
Mark Sisson[9] and Chris Kresser[10], two people for whom I have great respect, recently wrote about the pros and cons of the Carnivore Diet.
If you google “Carnivore Diet”, you’ll find many anecdotal reports on the Internet describing the benefits of this lifestyle change. For more in-depth discussions of the medical benefits of the Carnivore Diet, I recommend Dr. Paul Saladino’s website (https://carnivoremd.com/the-carnivore-diet-start-here/). He is an MD who highly recommends and personally follows a strict Carnivore Diet.
My Experiment
So, I am connecting some of the medical dots that I am researching. I believe the benefits of a Carnivore Diet will assist my body’s challenge to heal from IgA Kappa Light Chain Multiple Myeloma. As you may recall, my original prognosis at the time of my diagnosis in September 2018 was that I could be dead by the end of 2018. I’ve surprised a lot of people!
Let me be very clear though. I am not recommending that cancer patients should be on the Carnivore Diet. I will experiment with it and will describe below exactly what I will be doing for my personal use. Again, there is no published proof that what I am including in my 10 Unconventional Cancer Protocols is going to treat my cancer or anyone’s cancer. But all my research has proven to me that what you eat and what you eliminate from your diet are vital for overall health.
Potential Benefits of Carnivore Diet
- Restricts calories and mimics fasting: Protein is filling, so you eat less. Eating less reduces caloric intake. Reducing caloric intake will decrease insulin production, insulin-like growth factor, and growth hormone. Fasting (which restricts caloric intake for a period of time) triggers autophagy where old cells die and damaged cells repair. The end result is reduced inflammation as well as reduced symptoms of chronic and autoimmune diseases.
- Provides low residue in gut: This diet is basically protein and fat – all of which are absorbed in the upper part of the gut. So, there is little leftover residue to irritate or inflame the lower portions of the gut. Less residue in the lower gut reduces diarrhea, bloating, gas, and abdominal pain while helping prevent inflammatory bowel disease and irritable bowel syndrome. Also, the Carnivore Diet avoids oxalates and lectins that could be damaging to the body.
- Alters the gut microbiome: A healthy gut microbiome is vital for optimum immune health and reduction of inflammatory diseases.[11] However, altering the gut microbiome may have positive as well as negative effects.[12] Microbial diversity and homeostasis are key to a healthy microbiome.
- Supplies pre-digested nutrients: Eating an animal from nose-to-tail provides all the nutrients that support that animal’s health. The nutrients that are consumed by the animal are present in their muscles, fat, cartilage and collagenous parts, and their organs. Eating wild caught or pastured animals from nose-to-tail provides us with all these nutrients, which may be in sufficient quantity and quality for us to thrive.[13]
- Creates ketones: A Carnivore Diet will put the body into a state of ketosis. Ketosis will shift the body to burning fat or ketones for energy instead of burning glucose. Cancer cells cannot utilize ketones, but our remaining healthy cells can. As I mentioned above, cancer patients might have significant results from being in a state of ketosis even though there are no controlled, long-term human studies to support this.[14]
My Updated Unconventional Cancer Protocol
I’m going to tweak my 10 Unconventional Cancer Protocols by replacing my current diet program with the Carnivore Diet along with a few of my modifications. I will follow this eating program for at least 1-2 months to see how my biomarkers react and how I feel. This experiment may become the way I will eat forever going forward. It should be no surprise to you that my ultimate decision maker or breaker will be how I feel. Of course, I will continue with my other integrated cancer protocols daily.
I’ll eat when I’m hungry and drink when I’m thirsty. Although I purchase most of my pastured and wild-caught animal products from neighborhood grocers and local farmers’ markets, I purchase what I can’t find from White Oak Pastures[15] in Georgia or VitalChoice[16] in Washington.
My Carnivore Diet
- Intermittent fasting, which is part of my current diet – probably easier to do on a Carnivore Diet because proteins and fats are more satiating
- Pastured animal meats and their healthy fats (including organs like pork and chicken liver, sweetbreads, skin, cartilage and collagenous parts)
- Wild caught seafood – especially sardines, salmon, shrimp, mussels, and salmon roe
- Butter or ghee from grass-fed and pastured cattle
- Raw cheeses
- Pastured chicken eggs
- Homemade bone broth
- Spices, sea salt, and herbs for flavor
- One cup of organic coffee with raw heavy cream in the morning
- Freeze-dried Organ Complex[17] and Freeze-Dried Bone Marrow[18] (supplied by Enviromedica from grass-fed cattle in New Zealand)
My Daily Cancer Protocols
- To support my gut: I take 2 caps of Megasporebiotic, 2 caps of HU58, 2 caps of RestorFlora, 8 caps of MegaIgG2000, and 1 scoop of MegaPrebiotic mixed with 1 scoop of MegaMucosa in cold water (all products from Microbiome Labs). I also take 2 caps of TerraFlora (from Enviromedica).
- To support my bone: I take 6 caps of OsteoVegan (from NuMedica), 4 caps of Megaquinone K2-7 (from Microbiome Labs), and 25,000 IU of Vitamin D3 (from Nutrigold).
- To assist killing cancer cells: I take 6 caps of Salvestrol Platinum 2000 (from Salvestrol).
- To support my immune system: I take 3 herbal liquid extracts from MediHerb: 5.0 ml of Echinacea Premium 1:2; 2.5 ml of Korean Ginseng 1:2; and 5.0 ml of Astragalus 1:2. Also from MediHerb, I add 5.0 ml of Marshmallow Root 1:5 Glycetract to the 3 herbal liquid extracts for mucous membrane support and as a “sweetener” for the other 3 “bitter” elixirs.
- To help repair my mitochondria: I use PEMF (Pulsed Electromagnetic Field) Therapy using the PureWave full-body mat[19] first thing in the morning for 8-minutes at setting “Vital – 10”, afternoon session for 8-minutes at setting “Basis – 10”, in early evening for 8-minutes at setting “Relax – 4”, and at bedtime for 24-minutes at setting “Relax – 1”.
- To control pain: I take 600-800mg of ibuprofen only when necessary.
- To target specific proteins involved in my cancer, I take 2 human-derived monoclonal antibody immunotherapies: XGEVA injections attack a protein that causes my bones to weaken and inactivates this protein. Darzalex infusions attack a specific protein on the surface of malignant plasma cells and kills them. Along with the Darzalex, I am given premeds (Tylenol, Benadryl, and Decadron) just before the infusion to limit any side effects.
- To help prevent colds and flu: I use a Bee Propolis Mouth Spray 4 times a day if I feel any “scratchiness” in my throat (from Beekeeper’s Naturals).
- To strengthen my body: Based on the condition of my skeleton, I perform appropriate upper body and lower body exercises several days a week at home. It’s essential for me to avoid any “twisting” motions because of my risk for additional pathological fractures. Also, I walk about one mile outside a few days a week. As my body strengthens, I’ll incorporate a more challenging routine.
That’s it for now. I started the Carnivore Diet on January 1, 2020. My Unconventional Cancer Journey is taking a turn to more experimentation, which is my New Year’s Resolution. This is how I roll.
Up until now, I have had success maintaining my quality of life. Maybe my bone marrow cancer will go into remission, or maybe I can cure this malignancy. Who knows? Certainly, conventional oncologists don’t know. By checking my cancer biomarkers as I progress with the Carnivore Diet, I will know for sure. I’m prepared for all outcomes.
[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6603809/
[2] https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/5875/48f7a3e96e9173be688689d5e0b013791a07.pdf
[3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4618885/
[4] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2213231717307565
[5] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4950268/
[6] http://pubs.sciepub.com/ajmcr/4/8/8/
[7] https://www.openfuture.biz/expertise/AndrewScarborough.html
[8] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5842847/
[9] https://www.marksdailyapple.com/the-carnivore-diet-pros-cons-and-suggestions/
[10] https://chriskresser.com/the-carnivore-diet-is-it-really-healthy/
[11] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23618829
[12] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3957428/
[13] https://carnivoremd.com/what-to-eat-on-a-carnivore-diet-your-carnivore-diet-meal-plan/
[14] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5450454/
[15] https://www.whiteoakpastures.com/
[16] https://www.vitalchoice.com/
[17] https://shop.enviromedica.com/pastured-organ-complex
[18] https://shop.enviromedica.com/pastured-bone-marrow
[19] https://www.purewavenow.com/product/pemf-home-system/
Schedule a ”30-Minute Free Consult” with me to answer some of your questions and determine if we are a good fit for a coaching program! CLICK HERE.
If you don’t want to miss out on new posts, sign up for my “Belly Bites” Newsletter HERE.
16 Comments
Great to hear you are doing well. I having diagnosed with a rare disease. Tarlov Cyst disease. It is s connective tissue disease. What do you recommend me to take in order to boost my inmune system?. thank you very much
Yes! I am so happy you are starting a carnivore diet! I’m 45 yo, and I’ve followed a strict primal/paleo diet (via Mark Sisson) for almost 7 years now and found that while it initially helped to reverse my lifelong IBS, the IBS returned after I got accidentally glutened about 2 years into the diet. I also began to develop arthritis and random joint pain, insomnia, chronic shoulder/neck pain, and menstrual cycle disturbances several years into the diet, suggesting I was developing increased inflammation. I started the carnivore diet Feb 1, 2019 (when my third attempt at keto only exacerbated my symptoms) and quickly learned that I was dealing with oxalate overload. The IBS and most of the pain-related symptoms are a thing of the past now. I still deal with intermittent lower back pain, some menstrual cycle disturbances and insomnia, but it seems to come in waves, and I believe it is part of “oxalate dumping” from the tissues in my body. I’m a cancer biologist and have come to believe fervently that “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure” so I plan to stick with this diet forever. Good luck. I am so confident you are on the right track and that this diet is going to help you tremendously.
I was wondering if I should suggest that you try this given how nutrient dense the carnivore diet is. The number of anecdotal stories I’ve been reading lately is impressive. Many of them can be found at meatrx.com, Dr. Shawn Baker’s new venture.
Thanks for the links to the case studies.
I’m switching to a carnivore diet myself as an elimination diet to handle an autoimmune condition. My fridge and freezer are now filled only with nutritious animal products, plus I have canned fish (wild-caught sardines and tuna).
It’s taking some practice to eat only when hungry and and to stop when the hunger is give (not when “full”, r normal signal I and many other unfortunately use). I’m enjoying monitoring my body in this new way. However, on carnivore I’m finding I am satiated very quickly. I haven’t calculated if I am eating more or fewer calories but it certainly seems to be less food.
Coming is much simpler and faster now, too. Much less prep and cleanup. And I am tempted to buy an Otto Grill to make it even easier. (Or the less expensive light version; there are other competitors on the market, too.)
Ottogrills.com
The vegan crowd says that eating meat increases mtor but I’ve not been convinced that it’s a long-term issue for humans. As Saladino points out and we know from our paleo studies, humans or our direct ancestors have been eating meat for perhaps 6 million years. it seems likely to me that once we shifted to meat-eating, that became our primary source of nutrients and we used vegetation as backup when there were several days without a successful hunt or a sort of supplementation.
Thank you for the update and I continue to wish you well in your journey.
Dr Danenberg, Have you heard of the book—Any Way You Can. Please check it out– ANYWAY YOU CAN: Doctor Bosworth Shares Her Mom’s Cancer Journey: A BEGINNER’S GUIDE TO KETONES FOR LIFE Paperback – February 15, 2018
by Annette Bosworth M.D. (Author) I have the audio book and it was one of the most pleasurable reading time for me. It will affirm what you are trying right now and fill you with hope
You will find many more Cancer healing books by Vegans, by cutting out meat and all animal proteins which increase IGF1/HGH which has been linked to cancer growth, mets and angiogenesis, meat makes things grow, so do high glycemic junk foods and soy Isolyate powder etc., eating a carnivore diet is too dangerous for a cancer patient I would have thought, a low fat vegan diet with cancer fighting foods like crucifers, berries, beans, salads would almost shut down IGF1 via the diet, wouldnt that be better?
I suggest you read some of the case reports from the Paleomedicina Clinic in Budapest, Hungary. The medical team has treated over 5,000 patients with severe chronic diseases and cancer since 2011 with their Paleolithic Ketogenic Diet. https://paleomedicina.com/en/#blog
Thanks for your reply, yes I did hear about the clinic, i have been directed here many times by keto/carnivore guys, it looks interesting.
May I add that I have serious cancer fears and had them most of my life, having watched Dr Saladinos videos and listened to what he has to say, many things make sense, but we all have biases, for example he may talk about The China Study (that suggest the more meat one eats the more disease) and yet states that people in Hong Kong eat the most meat and live the longest, you get my point here … both are kind of the same epidemiological studies if Im not mistaken, and so he cherry picks, but that is normal, so does Dr Greger or other vegan docs, when he talk about plant toxins and them probably not having a net benefit and that we can boost Sirts, Nrf2 etc via external Hormetic activity, he has a point, and I suppose I would agree with most of what he says – I had a similar theory, its a Daoist one, there is yin and YANG in everything and so when he talks about other people suggesting how great plant polyphenols are for example (YANG) they seldom report the yin, the bad effects, the same rule must be applied to Meat, Meat CANNOT only be YANG, it must have some bad things about it, some negatives.
Intermittent fasting, not eating grains, restricting to mono diet are all not new, infact the Daoists and mountain men spoke about these to become superhuman and extend life, they talk about all the hormetic activities that are all the rage nowadays, ability to stay n the cold, the heat, walking long distances, meditation, cutting off grains, fasting etc, when they spoke about diet they would add life prolonging herbs or roots and would abstain from all food (normal food) and so a restriction to only a few food that they thought had medicinal properties.
I did see a study were women who ate more of a variety of plants had less disease than those who ate the same calories roughly but fewer variety, lets say 5 types of plants instead of 15 types, this kind of shows the opposite of what Dr Saladino suggests, the study show a positive synergistic affect (YANG) what about the negative synergistic effects? There definitely will be more going on on a microscopic/dna level but it seems that somehow they are healthier than the ladies eating fewer variety and so this leads me to believe that the microbiome is healthier and affecting the health of those women positively.
Dr Saladino talks about Sulforaphane in petri dish experiments if Im not mistaken showing that they destroy dna and yet doesnt allow the ideo that animal proteins or increased IGF1 can affect cancer cause its only an in vitro study, you see my point? I love the guy, and think he is onto something, but he doesnt know it yet 😉
I have tried the Carnivore diet, and its great as an elimination diet, some seem to thrive on it for years, I think I’ll test on my own mice the carnivore diet vs a low fat vegan diet and see, no doubt if the Carni group die or have more disease people will say, oh well you can’t extrapolate to humans, they are mice!
If its working great for you then, then thats really good, have you seen one guy in the states that eats raw meat only, his name is Mr Nance, unbelievable and he has been going for 11yrs or more.
I did the same and my total cholesterol skyrocketed from 155 to 451.
Wow and thank you for sharing your journey!
Have you checked out the work of dr jack kruse of the kruse longevity centre (mitochondrial health & repair) thought you may find his work helpful for your healing
Sending prayers for you and wishes for recovery and good health!
Hi Alan, Deuterium levels are key on cancer , thats why carnivore diet works (wild or grassfed animal fats are deuterium depleted) and even Deuterium depleted water treatments it wolud be helpeful look.: https://www.ddcenters.com/ https://podcast.nourishmeorganics.com.au/dr-laszlo-boros-on-deuterium-depletion-for-optimal-health
You are amazing.
Thank you, Dr. Al!
Look at Paleomedicina in Hungry
I was so happy to see this, having recently been diagnosed w breast cancer and it has fully broken out of my skin. One of the lymph nodes is super painful at times, but I decided to fully give up sugar and harmful carbs and now I’m doing MMS for the past 6 months, as well as B17 and have just started the Carnivore diet about 6 days ago.
I haven’t done any chemo, surgery or radiation, and haven’t had any biopsies. t really helps to see people doing things in other ways – I wish you all the best and will look to see your updates periodically. I know and have seen many cancer patients do really well on various ‘alt’ healing modalities. Why not more?
This is interesting! I totally agree with what you brought up here. I am glad I stumbled upon this!
I wish you the best of luck in this
Comments are closed for this article!